Top 10 American Idol Performances

  • CevherShare

So there is some Buzz around American Idol as they gear up for the upcoming season.  Got me thinking about the best performances on the show’s history.  Now, I didn’t watch the first few seasons, but have been hooked for the majority of the show’s run at this point.  I am 100% sure that I will leave out your favorite song (Fantasia and Clay never really did it for me and I turned in my Soul Patrol membership card long ago)…so leave it in the comments!

Honorable Mentions:

Carly Smithson – everything from her…I loved her!

Chris Sligh – “Typical”

Constantine Maroulis – “Bohemian Rhapsody”

Jason Castro – “Hallelujah”

Blake Lewis – “Somewhere Only We Know”

10) Jordin Sparks – “A Broken Wing” – Completely unexpected excellence

9) Kelly Clarkson – “Stuff Like That There” – Nobody has embraced a theme week quite like her!


8) David Archuleta – “Imagine” – I was never a big Archuleta fan, but this was powerful.

7) Jennifer Hudson – “Circle of Life” – She’s incredible!

6) David Cook – “Hello” – I’m a huge fan of this underdog winner!

5) Adam Lambert – “Mad World” – This upped the game for every performance on the show moving forward.

4) Lakisha Jones – “And I’m Telling You” – She OWNED that stage and that song!

3) Carrie Underwood – “Alone” – The ultimate “chick rock” song done with tiny country twang and it WORKS!

2) Kris Allen – “Heartless” – Kris won over America when he performed this song, delivering a better version than Kanye West or The Fray could ever imagine.

1) Chris Daughtry – “Hemmorhage (In My Hands)” – Simply put, this was the single-biggest star-cementing performance I’ve seen on the show.  At this moment, it was clear to me that we were looking at the genesis of a rock god.  For me, no performance on the show has delivered the goods like this one.

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Rascal Flatt's Broken Road by Carrie Underwood deserves a mention.

I'd pick Jason Castro's Hallelujah as #1. I've never been as moved by any other song on AI. His voice is unique and lovely.

Honorable mention for Jason Castro's "Hallelujah"? I think it ranks up there in #1, 2, 3rd slot. That's all, except I thought Clay Aiken's "Solitare" should be an honorable mention.

Kris Allen above Adam Lambert and Jason Castro? You have seriously lost it.

Hallelujah belongs at #1 0r #2 behind Mad World or vise versa and Hemmorage #3.

Allen has no power, no range and reduces every song to 5 notes.

Thankfully Idol concert goers feel differently half are exiting during Heartless to get to the barricades to hopefully meet Adam.

I haven't watched AI much before this season but I found all of Kris Allen performances fantastic, some brilliant, and Heartless was the BOMB! A killer performance.

Great pick with David Cook. For me, that was the performance that made me sit up and take notice. He's my favorite!

It was impressive when Clay Aiken performed Bridge Over Troubled Water with the choir backing him up. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QC9SKjdoTXg

What about billie jean by Cook...loved it..

Excellent choice, Chris! I gave "Hello" the David Cook spot because I found it more original. I have many of Cook's performances on my iPod for good reason! I could have made a Cook/Daughtry/Allen top 10!

Daughtry is by far my favorite American Idol contestant, and that performance was amazing. I'm glad their albums have done so well, they deserve all their success!

I would say you forgot some Ruben, I loved him.

Totally agree on Ruben. I thought he was excellent the entire season, but couldn't find one stand-out performance. I love that Carly Smithson has formed a new group the remnants of Evanesence!