Breaking Down LeBron’s Options

  • CevherShare

Tonight is the night!  LeBron James will announce on a live special on ESPN who will pay him to

Cleveland Cavaliers' LeBron James reacts to a play against the Boston Celtics during the fourth quarter in Game 6 of their NBA Eastern Conference playoff basketball series in Boston, Massachusetts, in this May 13, 2010 file photo. July 1, 2010 marks the opening day of the free-agent signing period amid intense media speculation about whether James, the NBA's Most Valuable Player for the past two seasons, will remain at Cleveland. REUTERS/Adam Hunger/Files (UNITED STATES - Tags: SPORT BASKETBALL)

play basketball!  (If your guess is “Nike,” you win snark points, but snark doesn’t help us solve this mystery.)

So let’s quickly break down his top options:

Cleveland Cavaliers – Who doesn’t want to be THAT guy who grows up somewhere, elevates the town and stays there?  He would be the American Icon, the Hometown Hero — the Demigod of Ohio.  He would be THE show, the undisputed King of Cleveland.  He would have an unprecedented level of control over the organization for the next 15-20 years – and beyond, should he choose to go into coaching, managing, or even owning an organization.  Don’t forget, the Cavs can pay him the most money under the NBA’s Collective Bargaining Agreement.

Miami Heat – If LeBron joined the Heat, he would be a part of the most talented trio of players in generations, with Dwyane  Wade and Chris Bosh.  Miami is a party town and a bigger market than Cleveland, for sure.  However, he would be joining Wade’s team.  He’d be a tri-Captain, instead of THE MAN.  To do so, he’d have to take less money from the league and hope that endorsements and outside ventures help his bank account.  On the flip side, the pressure to win for a decade straight would be immense.  Anything short of an annual trophy hoist would be deemed  a failure.  So, to summarize: less money, less control, less spotlight, more pressure.  Don’t see it happening.

New York Knicks – If ever a team needed a savior, it’s the Knicks.  Burdened by bad drafts, poor coaching, terrible chemistry (or, to quote Charles Barkley: “just turrible”) and shady management, LeBron would give new hope to the #1 market.  He would take the franchise from an afterthought to a legitimate contender.  Plus, Amar’e Stoudamire, while an excellent player in his own right, could easily be the Pippen to James’ Jordan.  For someone who has said on the record he wants to be a “global brand,” living in NYC could go a long way in helping the cause.  The downside, of course, is the increased pressure to pump new life in a moribund organization.  I would say there would be increased media scrutiny, but James is a national player – everything he does is examined on a higher level.   The special is being filmed at former Knick star Allen Houston’s Greenwich, CT, estate.  Does that mean anything?  Or is it just a convenience place for ESPN to film on short notice?

Washington Wizards – Just making sure you’re paying attention!

Chicago Bulls – How do you become the greatest of all-time?  You can try by leading his former team.  While most people wouldn’t want to work under the shadow of Michael Jordan – the original “global brand” basketball star – James has seemed quite open to the possibility.  Outfielder for the New York Yankees…Quarterback for the Dallas Cowboys…Forward on the Detroit Red Wings…playing these positions carries a mystique.  Leader of the Chicago Bulls may have that pull for James.  Do not forget that their roster is built to win for years to come.  The supporting cast is there and the salary structure appears to be in good shape.  Unlike Miami, where it would be the stars and nobodies, this team can grow together for a decade.

My Take – It makes the most sense for him to stay in Cleveland.  Why would someone rip the heart out of his hometown on national TV?   In all seriousness, what opportunities, exactly, would be more open to him if he played in another city?  None.  He has the connections and finances to call his own shots.

Where do you think he’ll end up tonight?

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Awww, sorry, Mike. It seems that he did rip out the heart of Cleveland.... :( Bobby is a HUGE fan of bball, he played in middle & high school.....he want James to stay, too.....

It's the final countdown! Wish it was NY (as a Knicks fan), but betting on Miami. Lol about including the Wizards in that mix.

I'm so sick of this media frenzy, but it's like a train wreck I can't stop watching or commenting or discussing! My money's on Miami, maybe New York second and Cleveland third. There's no way he's going to literally live in Jordan's shadow in Chicago. And he's not going to win in Cleveland or New York. I think Bosh and Wade have convinced him that coming to Miami will be the best thing to do to get a championship in the next year or two.

I mean really, if you're already a millionaire and getting even more from the numerous endorsements - doesn't it become more about the championships and your legacy than your bank account? What's the first thing you think about when you hear the names Steve Nash, Patrick Ewing, Karl Malone, John Stockton, Reggie Miller? No championships! I don't think LeBron wants to be in that category. Especially when Kobe is about to run out of fingers for his rings.

I think it's definitely between Miami and Cleveland, and I actually would lean Miami. Let me explain.

One, you're not exactly right on less money in Miami... Florida has no state income tax, and apparently LeBron would get more from a 5 year contract in Miami than a 6 year contract in Cleveland.

Also, sure, the pressure is going to be on in Miami to win championships, but he CAN win them in Miami. I'm not sure he'll ever win a championship in Cleveland, much less multiple championships. Does he really want to even allow that as a possibility?

As for Miami being D-Wade's town, a team can handle more than one superstar. Magic and Kareem did it for years, and I wouldn't exactly say they have small egos. Sure it flamed out between Shaq and Kobe, but they won three championships first.

I like the idea of hometown loyalty myself... I'd love to see superstars play their entire careers in one place (as a St. Louis Cardinals fan, we're going to be facing this same situation with Pujols soon). But I don't think LeBron is really the hometown guy people are making him out to be... after all, he's the guy who wore a Yankees cap to an Indians playoff game.

Agree on the Miami situation. The Heat is D'Waynes team. LeBron's ego can't handle that.

Chicago- This man is already in the shadows of MJ with everyone comparing him to the real "king." I doubt he'd want to walk past a bronze statue of the man every. single. day. Talk about pressure.

I'd like him to go to the Knicks- mostly because I'm tired of seeing him with the Cavs. It's like beating a dead horse...they keep reaching the same point every season, when will they advance? The same way he revamped the Cavs, he can do so for the Knicks...that franchise definitely needs some help, and picking up Stoudamire is not going to automatically do it for them.

But, I agree with you. I doubt he would devastate the people of Cleveland in this manner and I see him staying with the Cavs for a few more years. He owns Cleveland, why would he walk away from that?